Jiva Technology

What History can teach us about technology

Every now and then the argument resurfaces. Are some subjects more valuable than others? Are some degrees a good idea and others … well, worthless? The argument is usually framed as ‘technical’ or STEM subjects versus the liberal arts, where studying medicine is patently worthwhile and studying renaissance painting less so. It can feel as though science and technology has all the arguments – even if we’re talking about obscure mathematics or unusual chemistry that has no apparent application, we know from past experience that even the oddest topics can suddenly be found useful. Sometimes hundreds of years later. Riemann geometry anyone?

But there’s a subtlety here that is perhaps overlooked. Take for example the study of history. It feels as though we live in interesting times where technological and political upheaval is on the horizon. But is it so far outside the norm? Is this perhaps where historians can help us? May Beard is a fabulous example of a historian whose deep knowledge of long dead people and their customers is actually terribly relevant to the world we live in today. And I came across an example which struck me had equal bearing on a world staring down the barrel of artificial intelligence, bioinformatics and driverless cars. The first bridge across the Thames was built in 50 AD, around the site of the current London Bridge. The second wasn’t built until 1,700 years later. In the meantime, the gap was filled by numerous Thames ferrymen who plied their trade, were licensed and made a decent living from it. In the 1800’s, bridge building began nearest and a new technology (the bridge) displaced thousands of ferrymen jobs. The response of the government was interesting. They compensated the ferrymen for their loss of earnings and in some cases, continue to do so today.

What history offers is a toolbox, an understanding of examples from the past and a grasp of what would or would not be outside the norm. For the tech industry grappling with the cultural (and political) upheaval they’re about to unleash on us, perhaps a few students of history might be a useful addition to the armies of engineers and mathematicians. It shows that advanced skills have their uses and sometimes it pays to look beyond the obvious, to engage in some second and third order thinking to really solve a problem. Its one thing to create new science and new technologies, its quite another to get people to accept it. And if it fails to get accepted, that technology is another of those useless topics we were talking about earlier.


Your student loan: is it a debt, is it a tax?

Here’s a thing: the dictionary definition of a loan is simple, “a thing that is borrowed, especially a sum of money that is expected to be paid back with interest”. So far, so straightforward. On that basis, a student loan is money that you borrow to pay for your studies and associated living expenses and then pay back once you enter the world of work. Plus of course the interest, which is currently running at an eye popping 6.1 per cent.

But hand on a minute, why does every self-respecting personal finance commentator and newspapers ranging from the Financial Times to the Guardian suggest that your student loan isn’t actually a loan? Simple, because most people are not expected to pay it back. Current IFS estimates are that 83% of graduates won’t repay. And if 83 in 100 people who take out a loan don’t pay it back, then its no longer a loan in any real sense of the word.

Does any of this matter? Who cares if only a few people pay back the money? Well it does matter and it matters for a few important reasons that no one seems to be talking about. Student debt has already ballooned to over £100bn and sooner or later someone has to pick up the tab. Politicians have engaged in a classic classic fudge where they tell one group of people one thing (its a loan, we’ll get the money back) and another group of people another (don’t worry, you probably won’t have to pay). The money has already been spent on those shiny new campus building and extravagant Vice Chancellor salaries, so what happens when student debt becomes a problem for the Government or taxpayers who don’t go to university realise they’re picking up the tab anyway.

What’s more, why are we telling people to take out debt and then not worry about repaying it? It sounds like the definition of a bad habit to get into. Student debt appears to be yet another topic that we cannot have an honest public debate. This won’t go away if we don’t think about it, it just gets worse. There are only two solutions: most of the debt is picked up by taxpayers or most of the debt is picked up by students. What I fear more than anything is that the rules will change – we’ll start telling students its okay and they won’t have to pay and then switch as the debt mountain becomes too high. That, more than anything, would be the epitome of unfairness.

David v Goliath

Its hard to avoid the excitement surrounding Bristol City at the moment. I may hail from the blue side of town and have always been more interested in the fortunes of Bristol Rugby over Bristol City and Bristol Rovers, but tomorrow sees a big day for “The City”. The local team take on the giants of Manchester City, having already engaged in the David-like downing of Manchester United. Lets hope they do themselves proud. Manchester City have already endeared themselves by extending a VIP invite to Bristol City ball boy and viral social media sensation Jaden Neale. His celebrations on the touchline with Bristol City manager Lee Johnson will no doubt earn him an honourable mention on next years SPOTY. You can only imagine the tales he’ll be telling classmates when he gets back from meeting Pep Guardiola and the boys. He’ll be dining out on it for years. Its amazing how sport can energise a city and with table-topping Bristol Rugby unbeaten (and playing like a rugby version of Brazil to boot), it looks as though the Damp Dip (as we like to call it) might be about to punch its weight in sporting terms at long last. So here’s to Bristol City as they take on a team that cost more than every single Bristol City team in history. Enjoy yourselves and do us proud.


Regus House
1 Friary

Temple Quay
United Kingdom